Hathaway Excalibur 72-in Air Hockey or Hathaway Phantom II 90-in Air? Which Hathaway Model to Buy
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Links on this page are affiliate links.
The hathaway excalibur 72 in air hockey vs phantom ii 90 in air comparison highlights two distinct game room options. Both models feature electronic scoring and poly-sealed playfields for consistent puck movement. They also include built-in leg levelers to ensure a flat surface on uneven floors. The main difference lies in size and function. The Excalibur offers a 72-inch 2-in-1 design with a table tennis top, while the Phantom II provides a larger 90-inch dedicated air hockey experience with dual commercial-grade blowers.
Key differences
| Aspect | Hathaway Excalibur 72-in 2-in-1 Table | Hathaway Phantom II 90-in Air Hockey Table |
|---|---|---|
| Table Size | 72 inches | 90 inches |
| Multi-Game Configuration | 2-in-1 (Air Hockey & Table Tennis) | Air Hockey Only |
| Blower Motor Power | High-output single motor | Dual 110V UL-approved motors |
| Weight | 88 pounds | 190 pounds |
| Color | Driftwood, Black | Blue / White / Silver |
Which one should you choose?
Choose Hathaway Excalibur 72-in 2-in-1 Table if
- You want a versatile table that converts to table tennis
- You have limited floor space and need a lighter unit
- You prefer a rustic farmhouse aesthetic with driftwood finishes
Choose Hathaway Phantom II 90-in Air Hockey Table if
- You prioritize a larger 90-inch playing surface for serious play
- You want stronger airflow from dual commercial-grade blowers
- You prefer a modern arcade look with chrome accents
Verdict: The Excalibur suits buyers who need a compact, multi-game solution with a rustic design. The Phantom II is better for those seeking a dedicated, large-format air hockey table with superior airflow. Choose based on your space constraints and whether you value table tennis conversion over dedicated air hockey performance.
Size, Multi-Game, and Build
Table size
The Hathaway Excalibur 72-in 2-in-1 Table measures 72 inches in length. This standard size fits well in most home game rooms. The Hathaway Phantom II 90-in Air Hockey Table is significantly larger at 90 inches long. This extra length provides a wider playing area for more strategic shots. If you have limited floor space, the Excalibur is the more compact choice. However, if you want a professional arcade feel, the Phantom II offers a larger surface. The width also differs, with the Phantom II being 50 inches wide compared to the Excalibur's 40 inches. Both require substantial room for play and movement.
Multi-game configuration
The Excalibur stands out as a two-in-one game table. It converts from air hockey to table tennis by adding the included table tennis top. This poly-sealed black surface is designed for superb bounce on ping pong. The Phantom II is dedicated solely to air hockey. It does not include a conversion top for other games. If you want versatility in a single piece of furniture, the Excalibur offers more value. You can host different types of matches without needing separate tables. The Phantom II focuses entirely on delivering the best possible air hockey experience with its specialized design and airflow system.
Playfield coating
Both tables feature a poly-sealed playfield to ensure smooth puck movement. The Excalibur uses a poly-sealed surface that supports both air hockey and table tennis play. This coating protects the engineered wood underneath. The Phantom II also uses a poly-sealed playfield but specifies it as high-gloss. This high-gloss finish is intended to enhance the speed and consistency of the puck during fast-paced matches. While both coatings serve the same protective and functional purpose, the Phantom II emphasizes the high-gloss aspect for air hockey performance. The Excalibur prioritizes a finish that works well for table tennis bounce as well.
Blower motor power
The Phantom II includes dual 110V UL-approved blower motors. These commercial-grade motors channel powerful airflow through 3,500 holes. This dual setup ensures consistent lift for the puck across the entire 90-inch surface. The Excalibur features a high-output blower motor described as commercial-grade quality. However, the data does not specify if it is dual or single. It also does not list the number of air holes. For serious air hockey players, the Phantom II's dual motor system likely provides more reliable and uniform airflow. The Excalibur's motor is sufficient for general play but lacks the detailed specs of the Phantom II.
Build material
The Excalibur is constructed from 1-inch thick engineered wood. It features a driftwood melamine finish with light distressing and industrial black hardware. The base is an X-patterned design for stability. The Phantom II is built with MDF and PVC laminate. It includes chrome-plated ABS corners and a deep-blue melamine finish. The base is an arched pedestal design. Both tables use integrated or independent leg levelers to ensure a flat surface. The Excalibur uses independent levelers, while the Phantom II has built-in ones. The Phantom II is heavier at 190 pounds, suggesting a more substantial build compared to the Excalibur's 88 pounds.
Which Hathaway Air Hockey Table Fits You
Players wanting a versatile two-in-one table
The Excalibur converts to table tennis with an included top. Its 72-inch length and 88-pound weight make it easier to place in smaller rooms. The engineered wood construction and X-patterned base provide solid stability for mixed gameplay without requiring excessive floor space.
Users seeking commercial-grade airflow and speed
The Phantom II features dual 110V UL-approved blower motors with 3,500 holes. This system ensures powerful, consistent airflow for fast puck action. The high-gloss poly-sealed playfield reduces friction, allowing for rapid, arcade-style matches that maintain momentum without stopping for manual scoring adjustments.
Buyers prioritizing larger playing surface and durability
At 90 inches long and 190 pounds, this model offers a significantly larger playing area. The MDF and PVC laminate build with chrome details enhances long-term durability. The arched pedestal base and integrated levelers ensure a balanced surface for serious, high-energy competition in dedicated game rooms.
The products compared
Hathaway Excalibur 72-in 2-in-1 Table
Best for: compact game rooms needing table tennis
- Table Size
- 72 in
- Scoring Type
- In-rail electronic scoring
- Playfield Coating
- Poly-sealed
- Multi-Game Configuration
- 2-in-1
- Leg Levelers
- Independent leg levelers
- Dimensions
- 72 × 40 × 31 inches
View on Amazon: Hathaway Excalibur 72-in 2-in-1 Table Affiliate link
The Hathaway Excalibur is a 72-inch air hockey table with a driftwood finish. It features a commercial-grade blower and in-rail electronic scoring. The 2-in-1 design includes a table tennis top. It measures 72 by 40 inches and weighs 88 pounds. Independent leg levelers ensure stability. This model suits players who want a versatile table for multiple games.
Pros
- 72-inch playfield length
- 2-in-1 air hockey and table tennis
- In-rail electronic scoring
- Independent leg levelers
Cons
- 72-inch size is smaller than the 90-inch Phantom II
- 88-pound weight adds bulk
- 180-day warranty is shorter than typical standards
Good fit if
- You need a table tennis top included
- You have limited floor space
- You prefer a farmhouse aesthetic
Skip if
- You require a 90-inch playing surface
- You want a longer warranty period
- You prefer a sleek modern design
Verdict: Hathaway Excalibur 72-in Air Hockey is a solid choice for players who value versatility and a compact footprint over maximum playing size.
Hathaway Phantom II 90-in Air Hockey Table
Best for: large game rooms needing commercial-grade airflow
- Table Size
- 90 in L x 50 in W x 32 in H
- Blower Motor Power
- Dual 110V UL-approved blower motors
- Playfield Coating
- High-gloss, poly-sealed playfield
- Leg Levelers
- Built-in leg levelers
- Number of Players
- 2 players (2 strikers, 2 pucks included)
- Use
- Game Room, Commercial
View on Amazon: Hathaway Phantom II 90-in Air Hockey Table Affiliate link
The Hathaway Phantom II is a 90-inch air hockey table designed for game rooms and commercial use. It features dual 110V UL-approved blower motors and a high-gloss, poly-sealed playfield for consistent puck action. The electronic scoring system includes a built-in timer. Weighing 190 pounds, it offers a stable playing surface with built-in leg levelers. This model suits players seeking a larger, arcade-style experience.
Pros
- 90-inch length for extended gameplay
- Dual 110V UL-approved blower motors
- High-gloss, poly-sealed playfield
- Built-in electronic LED scoring and timer
Cons
- 190-pound weight makes relocation difficult
- 180-day limited warranty is shorter than industry standards
- No mention of app connectivity or remote control
Good fit if
- You have a large game room with sufficient floor space
- You prefer a larger 90-inch playing surface over standard sizes
- You want commercial-grade airflow for fast puck action
Skip if
- You have limited space in a smaller room
- You need a lightweight table for frequent moving
- You require a warranty longer than 180 days
Verdict: Hathaway Phantom II 90-in Air Hockey is a heavy-duty option for players who prioritize a larger playing area and powerful airflow. It fits best in dedicated game rooms where its 190-pound frame can remain stationary.
Specifications side by side
| Spec | Hathaway Excalibur 72-in 2-in-1 Table | Hathaway Phantom II 90-in Air Hockey Table |
|---|---|---|
| Table Size | 72 in | 90 in L x 50 in W x 32 in H |
| Blower Motor Power | not stated | Dual 110V UL-approved blower motors |
| Scoring Type | In-rail electronic scoring | not stated |
| Playfield Coating | Poly-sealed | High-gloss, poly-sealed playfield |
| Multi-Game Configuration | 2-in-1 | not stated |
| Leg Levelers | Independent leg levelers | Built-in leg levelers |
| Number of Players | not stated | 2 players (2 strikers, 2 pucks included) |
| Use | not stated | Game Room, Commercial |
| Dimensions | 72 × 40 × 31 inches | 90 × 50 × 32 inches |
| Weight | 88 pounds | 190 pounds |
| Color | Driftwood,Black | Blue / White / Silver |
| Model | BG50337 | BG50389 |
Frequently asked questions
Which Hathaway air hockey table is best for a small room?
The Hathaway Excalibur 72-in 2-in-1 Table is the better choice for compact spaces. Its 72-inch length and 40-inch width fit standard home game rooms. At 88 pounds, it is lighter and easier to position than the Phantom II. The Excalibur also offers a two-in-one design, converting to table tennis for added versatility in tight quarters.
How much space do I need for the Hathaway Phantom II?
You need a large area for the Hathaway Phantom II 90-in Air Hockey Table. It measures 90 inches long and 50 inches wide. The unit weighs 190 pounds, so it is designed to stay in one place. This commercial-grade model suits dedicated game rooms where you can accommodate its substantial footprint and heavy frame.
Does the Hathaway Excalibur have electronic scoring?
Yes, the Hathaway Excalibur 72-in 2-in-1 Table features electronic scoring. This system tracks points automatically during play. It helps you keep score without manual counting. The Excalibur shares this feature with the Phantom II, ensuring both models provide modern, convenient scoring for your gaming sessions.
Is the Hathaway Phantom II suitable for commercial use?
The Hathaway Phantom II 90-in Air Hockey Table is built for game rooms and commercial settings. Its 190-pound weight and sturdy construction support heavy use. The 90-inch length provides a larger playing area for competitive play. This model is ideal if you need a durable table for a busy environment or serious gameplay.
What is the weight difference between the two tables?
There is a significant weight difference between these two models. The Hathaway Excalibur weighs 88 pounds, making it manageable for home placement. The Hathaway Phantom II is much heavier at 190 pounds. This extra weight contributes to stability but means the Phantom II is less portable and best suited for permanent installation.
Can the Hathaway Excalibur be used for other games?
Yes, the Hathaway Excalibur 72-in 2-in-1 Table supports multiple games. It converts to table tennis with an included top. This two-in-one configuration allows you to switch between air hockey and ping pong. It is a practical option if you want to maximize the utility of your table in a single footprint.
What colors are available for the Hathaway Phantom II?
The Hathaway Phantom II 90-in Air Hockey Table comes in a Blue, White, and Silver color scheme. This color combination gives the table a distinct, professional look. The Excalibur is available in Driftwood and Black. You can choose the Phantom II if you prefer a bold, commercial-style aesthetic for your game room.